Book club

So, I joined a book club early last year. It's a relaxed affair that takes place once every 6 weeks or so in a cool little bar in Shimokitazawa. The beer flows along with the discussion. It does sometimes get very animated, but so far there hasn't been a drunken brawl. I do think, though that it's just a matter of time and a question of finding the right book.

I did initially intend to write a review of each of the books we read; an erudite record of the scholarly heights we scale, but as that doesn't really describe the nature of the meetings, I have since decided to summarize briefly either my own response or the consensus of the group.

These are the ones we've looked at so far; I'll bump it as we go along:


Ian McEwan – Solar: with the exception of one or two scenes, possibly the least funny comedy since Love Thy Neighbour, and yet strangely compelling as a narrative.







Kazuo Ishiguro – An Artist of the Floating World: absolutely fascinating study into the view the narrator has of the world/history and his place in it, and a running suggestion of how that might differ from anyone (everyone) else’s perspective. Poetic prose to boot.





Julian Barnes – The Sense of an Ending: referring to its winning the Booker; the sense of a carve-up more like. You wrote a nasty letter, you didn’t impregnate your girlfriend’s mother, so get over yourself, you dick.






John Banville – The Infinities: a lesson in taking a book on its own (de)merits, and not being influenced by the author’s other novels previously read. Possibly an example of the Chuck Berry/My ding-a-ling effect.






Graham Swift – Wish You Were Here: Careful, insightful study into the nature of family, lineage and responsibility. The plot springs on a spat that is hardly earth-shattering, which in turn means the denouement is somewhat predictable. There is also a feeling that Swift’s reveal is so ponderous that we actually don’t care one way or the other when it eventually comes. That’s a shame though, because the writing is wonderfully crafted, and the characters are beautifully drawn.  

Lionel Shriver – We Need to Talk About Kevin: well actually we don’t, to be perfectly honest. Especially if we’ve not thought things through first. Certainly not if you don’t really know what you’re talking about.






Patrick Dewitt – The Sisters Brothers: realistic, atmospheric, filmic western











Philip Roth – Portnoy’s Complaint: That Alex, what a wanker! The 'punchline' at the end of the novel is spot on, and we can 'start' by turning straight to Naomi's description of Alex in the preceding chapter.  

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Top 20...